5Multi-Platform Reputation
8.3/10
Rated on 3 platforms — Google 4.4, Yelp 5.0, Facebook 5.0; ratings agree
Phil Smith Roofing serves Victoria, BC and the surrounding area. Ask its customers and you’ll hear about fair pricing, professionalism, punctuality. It carries an N49 Trust Score of 58.9/100 across our 10-factor review.
4.4★ from 20 Google reviews
Rated on 3 platforms — Google 4.4, Yelp 5.0, Facebook 5.0; ratings agree
Has a website and a published email on its own domain
Not in the Google Maps local top results
~12.0 years on Google Maps (from total-reviews ÷ monthly rate)
Not on Three Best Rated / BBB
~32 reviews across 3 platforms
Single Google Business listing — no multi-area signals
On 2 extra platforms; reachable by website, email, phone
3 platforms linked: Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn · ~11 Facebook reviews
Get a free, no-obligation quote from one of Roofing’s most trusted teams.
By Charlene Wilson on Dec 24, 2025 Verified by Google
We had the best experience with Phil Smith roofing. The office coordinator and roofing crew exceeded our expectations with the quality of workmanship, timeliness of the project and cost. Thank you very much!
By Charlene Wilson on Dec 24, 2025 Verified by Google
We had the best experience with Phil Smith roofing. The office coordinator and roofing crew exceeded our expectations with the quality of workmanship, timeliness of the project and cost. Thank you very much!
By Michael Conn on Jun 13, 2025 Verified by Google
Nothing but problems from day one. Finally had to replace 35 year shingles that were installed in 2007, 18 years old. Roofing crew left large hole in soffit, had squirrels living in our attic, called Phil Smith, they looked at my home when I wasn't home and said they could find a hole, the hole was 6"X8", not hard to find, had to fix it myself. Roof had flashing installed backwards which caused numerous leaks and repainting required in my kitchen, again my expense to repair the roof flashing and to repaint. I had the roof patch repaired 3 times over the years, my expense. I finally gave up on the whole roof, 18 years into "35" year shingles, and had it replaced in 2004. Very disappointed!!!
By Michael Conn on Jun 13, 2025 Verified by Google
Nothing but problems from day one. Finally had to replace 35 year shingles that were installed in 2007, 18 years old. Roofing crew left large hole in soffit, had squirrels living in our attic, called Phil Smith, they looked at my home when I wasn't home and said they could find a hole, the hole was 6"X8", not hard to find, had to fix it myself. Roof had flashing installed backwards which caused numerous leaks and repainting required in my kitchen, again my expense to repair the roof flashing and to repaint. I had the roof patch repaired 3 times over the years, my expense. I finally gave up on the whole roof, 18 years into "35" year shingles, and had it replaced in 2004. Very disappointed!!!
By Garth Lenz on Nov 22, 2023 Verified by Google
Phil Smith Roofing did a wonderful job replacing our roof. The crew were very hard working, polite, and shared details about their work every step of the way. Working in challenging conditions dealing with November weather the team worked quickly and efficiently and the job was done on time and at a very fair price. I really can't think of enough good things to say about the job and the crew.
By Garth Lenz on Nov 22, 2023 Verified by Google
Phil Smith Roofing did a wonderful job replacing our roof. The crew were very hard working, polite, and shared details about their work every step of the way. Working in challenging conditions dealing with November weather the team worked quickly and efficiently and the job was done on time and at a very fair price. I really can't think of enough good things to say about the job and the crew.
By Olivia on Dec 5, 2022 Verified by Google
Requested a quote and after meeting Phil, I knew that this was the company that I would employ to replace my roof. Phil was very personable, knowledgeable and responsive. I was confident with the estimate and after mentioning the quote I received for chimney removal, Phil went out of his way to find a cheaper company. Excellent communication, friendly staff, and workmanship was well executed. Entire process from quote to completion was professional and seamless. Eternally grateful for the experience.
By Olivia on Dec 5, 2022 Verified by Google
Requested a quote and after meeting Phil, I knew that this was the company that I would employ to replace my roof. Phil was very personable, knowledgeable and responsive. I was confident with the estimate and after mentioning the quote I received for chimney removal, Phil went out of his way to find a cheaper company. Excellent communication, friendly staff, and workmanship was well executed. Entire process from quote to completion was professional and seamless. Eternally grateful for the experience.
By Rebekah Curran on Apr 29, 2022 Verified by Google
Fantastic service from start to finish! Phil offered clear and detailed explanations on what to expect during the process of having a new roof installed. The team was incredibly well-organized and finished the job within 3 days. They were also very careful to leave the area clean. We were highly impressed and will be recommending Phil Smith Roofing to our friends and family. Thank you, Phil!
By Rebekah Curran on Apr 29, 2022 Verified by Google
Fantastic service from start to finish! Phil offered clear and detailed explanations on what to expect during the process of having a new roof installed. The team was incredibly well-organized and finished the job within 3 days. They were also very careful to leave the area clean. We were highly impressed and will be recommending Phil Smith Roofing to our friends and family. Thank you, Phil!
Powered by 
Phil Smith Roofing 4.4 out of 5.0 based on 20 user reviews.